• About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Tuesday, June 28, 2022
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Seagull Media
  • COVID-19
    Covid-19

    Coronavirus seems to be under control in the Northeast

    COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities

    COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities

    Aerosols are a bigger coronavirus threat than WHO guidelines suggest

    Aerosols are a bigger coronavirus threat than WHO guidelines suggest

    Digital Contact Tracing

    Digital Contact Tracing

  • Economy+Business
    Searching The Internet

    75% Of Americans Turn To Internet For Health Information

  • Environment
  • Education
    Woman Studying

    Is Higher Education Hostile To Women Of Color?

    The White House

    The White House Is threatening To Cut funds To School Districts

  • Politics
    Ruth Bader Ginsburg

    Ginsburg Death Leaves Vacancy Ahead Of 2020 Election

    #WalkAway

    The Left practices Tolerance In The Most Superficial Ways

    President Trump Speaking At The White House

    President Trump Speaking At The White House

    Joe Biden, Dunmore, PA

    Joe Biden Speaks In Dunmore, PA

    Don’t expect Biden’s VP pick to make or break the 2020 election

    Don’t expect Biden’s VP pick to make or break the 2020 election

    Leaders like Trump fail if they cannot speak the truth and earn trust

    Leaders like Trump fail if they cannot speak the truth and earn trust

    Supreme Court reforms, strengthens Electoral College

    Supreme Court reforms, strengthens Electoral College

  • Science
    Why are scientists trying to manufacture organs in space?

    Why are scientists trying to manufacture organs in space?

  • History
    A summer of protest, unemployment and presidential politics – welcome to 1932

    A summer of protest, unemployment and presidential politics – welcome to 1932

    When France extorted Haiti – the greatest heist in history

    When France extorted Haiti – the greatest heist in history

  • U.S. Constitution
  • COVID-19
    Covid-19

    Coronavirus seems to be under control in the Northeast

    COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities

    COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities

    Aerosols are a bigger coronavirus threat than WHO guidelines suggest

    Aerosols are a bigger coronavirus threat than WHO guidelines suggest

    Digital Contact Tracing

    Digital Contact Tracing

  • Economy+Business
    Searching The Internet

    75% Of Americans Turn To Internet For Health Information

  • Environment
  • Education
    Woman Studying

    Is Higher Education Hostile To Women Of Color?

    The White House

    The White House Is threatening To Cut funds To School Districts

  • Politics
    Ruth Bader Ginsburg

    Ginsburg Death Leaves Vacancy Ahead Of 2020 Election

    #WalkAway

    The Left practices Tolerance In The Most Superficial Ways

    President Trump Speaking At The White House

    President Trump Speaking At The White House

    Joe Biden, Dunmore, PA

    Joe Biden Speaks In Dunmore, PA

    Don’t expect Biden’s VP pick to make or break the 2020 election

    Don’t expect Biden’s VP pick to make or break the 2020 election

    Leaders like Trump fail if they cannot speak the truth and earn trust

    Leaders like Trump fail if they cannot speak the truth and earn trust

    Supreme Court reforms, strengthens Electoral College

    Supreme Court reforms, strengthens Electoral College

  • Science
    Why are scientists trying to manufacture organs in space?

    Why are scientists trying to manufacture organs in space?

  • History
    A summer of protest, unemployment and presidential politics – welcome to 1932

    A summer of protest, unemployment and presidential politics – welcome to 1932

    When France extorted Haiti – the greatest heist in history

    When France extorted Haiti – the greatest heist in history

  • U.S. Constitution
No Result
View All Result
Seagull Media
No Result
View All Result
Home COVID-19

COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities

by THE GULL
July 14, 2020
in COVID-19
0
COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities
0
SHARES
69
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

COVID-19 makes clear that bioethics must confront health disparities

The Statue of Liberty. Stock Photo/Getty Images

Joseph J. Fins, Cornell University

With some reluctance, I’ve come to the sad realization the COVID-19 pandemic has been a stress test for bioethics, a field of study that intersects medicine, law, the humanities and the social sciences. As both a physician and medical ethicist, I arrived at this conclusion after spending months at what was once the epicenter of the pandemic: New York City. I was overseeing a 24/7 bioethics consultation service.

I work in a nationally ranked academic medical center in Manhattan. As it did with all hospitals in New York City, COVID-19 put us under tremendous pressure to respond to the surge of patients who came to us for care. In the early days, we struggled with inadequate provisions. Yet we persevered. We increased our ICU capacity by more than 200%, redeployed our clinical workforce in creative ways, and provided a “crisis standard of care.” Simply put, we did the best we could under extreme conditions. In all my years in medicine, I have seen nothing like it. I imagine the only analogy would be practicing medicine on a battlefield.

Outside Elmhurst Hospital’s trauma unit, where ambulances drop off many of the sick during the worst weeks of the pandemic. Getty Images / Andrew Lichtenstein

As challenging as our situation was, colleagues across New York City had it worse. I was especially struck by what hospitals experienced in the boroughs of Queens and the Bronx. Chronically under-resourced, they were also caring for patients who long suffered from the consequences of inadequate primary care. Those with untreated hypertension, diabetes, obesity, and other chronic conditions were especially prone to the ravages of coronavirus. The rows of refrigerator trucks outside a hospital in Elmhurst, Queens, parked there to temporarily hold the dead, was a horrifying symbol of the distress. As a scholar, I try to avoid becoming emotional, but seeing them reminded me, once again, of a battle: specifically, what my Dad had seen as a combat medic in World War II. But this was happening in New York City.

Such images have forced me to question the relevance of bioethics – and ask why my field hasn’t done more to identify these disparities and do something about them. To be sure, my team and I provided ethics consultations in our hospital, and I participated in policy discussions at the institutional and state level. But our focus for the most part was too narrow and ignored a tale of inequity unfolding around us.

One example: Our hospital in Manhattan evacuated patients from hospitals in Brooklyn and Queens to help with their case load. At the state level, there was talk to make things easier by coordinating such transfers. But mostly, the efforts were too little, too late. Inequity was baked into the system long before the pandemic. Nothing could be done to reverse that inequity, once waves of patients flooded the system.

Why hadn’t bioethics done more to anticipate these challenges and mitigate them? The answer is complex, and the history goes back generations.

Because of COVID-19, hospitals had to use refrigerated trucks as temporary morgues. Here, medical workers remove a body from one of those trucks outside Brooklyn Hospital in New York City. Getty Images / Stephanie Keith

Bioethics 101

Bioethics, a phrase coined in 1973, was a response to the Nazi atrocities in medicine, the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, and the challenges posed by increasingly sophisticated medical practice. Bioethics called for including the patient’s voice in care decisions, an affirmation of their rights, and a focus on four principles: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice.

[You need to understand the coronavirus pandemic, and we can help. Read The Conversation’s newsletter.]

But along the way, one of those principles was prized to the exclusion of the others. A European bioethicist once told me, with irony, that American medicine followed four ethical principles: autonomy and three others he could not recall.

Still, bioethics in the U.S. became something of a rights movement, akin to other civil rights movements of the era. The goal was to minimize hierarchies and give voice to the voiceless. The sanctioning of patient enfranchisement in bioethics was a response to entrenched paternalism (doctor knows best). Notably, it led to the right-to-be-left-alone and the right-to-die movement typified by cases like Karen Quinlan, Nancy Cruzan and Terri Schiavo.

With the elevation of self-determination, the pursuit of the other three principles – the promotion of good, the avoidance of harm, and the passion for social justice – was diminished. These limitations were laid bare by the morbidity and mortality data from the COVID-19 pandemic in New York City. Neighborhoods of color, poverty and poorer educational attainment were hardest hit – those very neighborhoods that had hospitals with an insufficient number of beds and poor access to primary care. The death rate in the Bronx was double that of Manhattan. This was a consequence of poverty, population density and the structural racism in medicine and health policy.

Bioethics needs to move beyond narrow questions of patient choice, particularly when the disenfranchised are not in a position to exercise that choice.

In 2009, as we prepared for an avian flu pandemic that never arrived, I posed these questions in an essay for the Hastings Center Bioethics Forum. I was worried about how entrenched and endemic disparities might compound the malign effects of a pandemic.

At that time, the average number of ventilators was 39.2 per 100,000 people in Manhattan, compared to 14.1 per 100,000 people in Queens. Imagining a pandemic flu, I worried that “rationing ventilators would be especially harsh in Queens” and would lead to “disproportionate death.” This is precisely what happened during the COVID-19 crisis a decade later.

While physicians and health care officials focus on the acute consequences of COVID-19, we must also recognize the real pathology existed long before the pandemic struck. The pre-existing condition of health care disparities led to the disproportionate burden on vulnerable communities from COVID-19.

Now is the time for bioethics to broaden its gaze and appreciate that rights without opportunity ring hollow. The Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen rightly observed the limited utility of negative rights if they did yield just results. Bioethics needs to learn from the COVID-19 experience lest its obsession with midcentury catechisms make it an historical artifact of an earlier era.

Joseph J. Fins, The E. William Davis Jr, M.D. Professor of Medical Ethics and Professor of Medicine at Weill Cornell Medicine, Cornell University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Tags: Contact TracingCOVID-19
THE GULL

THE GULL

Next Post
Covid-19

Coronavirus seems to be under control in the Northeast

Recommended

Don’t expect Biden’s VP pick to make or break the 2020 election

Don’t expect Biden’s VP pick to make or break the 2020 election

2 years ago
The White House

The White House Is threatening To Cut funds To School Districts

2 years ago
Rocky Point Park Gift Shop Rocky Point Park Gift Shop Rocky Point Park Gift Shop
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular News

    Connect with us

    Facebook Twitter Youtube

    © 2020 Seagull Media - News the way it should be told! site by RI Webmaster.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Business
    • National
    • World
    • Civil Rights
    • Politics
    • U.S. History
    • Science
    • Environment
    • Tech
    • Health

    © 2020 Seagull Media - News the way it should be told! site by RI Webmaster.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Create New Account!

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Add New Playlist